Cherry Bay Orchards Tart Cherry Concentrate 16oz Review
#1 of 9 · Best Overall✓ Label verified · Supplement Facts read Sep 7, 2026Real retailer photo, cut out. Label unedited.
Buy it. The form the studies used, especially for sleep. If your interest is the sleep/melatonin angle or you want to mirror the recovery trials, whole Montmorency concentrate beats capsules.
~$19.99~$1.25 / 1 oz serving
Why It Scores 7.9 — And The Label Line Behind Each Number
Form & Bioavailability
25% of scoreWhole-juice concentrate delivers the full anthocyanin-plus-melatonin matrix that capsules strip out, the form used in the sleep and marathon-recovery trials.
- Form
- Liquid Montmorency juice concentrate
Standardization & Dose
25% of scoreOne ounce is a real, trial-comparable serving, but it is a whole food so anthocyanin content varies by harvest and isn't standardized on the label.
- Dose
- 1 oz per serving (~60+ cherries equivalent)
- Standardization
- 100% pure juice, no standardized anthocyanin %
Third-Party Testing
20% of scoreKosher, Non-GMO and Gluten-Free, but no published third-party potency or contaminant certificate, so you trust the brand rather than a lab mark.
- Testing
- Kosher, Non-GMO, Gluten Free; no added sugar
Tolerability & Safety
15% of scoreWell tolerated; main caveat is natural fruit sugar and the tart taste. Not ideal for anyone limiting carbohydrate or sugar.
Value
15% of score~$19.99 for 16 servings is about $1.25 a serving for genuine 100% concentrate, strong value for the trial-matched form.
- Count
- 16 fl oz (16 servings)
- Cost per dose
- ~$1.25 per 1 oz serving
Label verified. Every figure read from the Supplement Facts photo, Sep 7, 2026.
Marketing Claims Vs. Reality
Whole concentrate matches the form used in tart cherry sleep research
Howatson 2012 and Pigeon 2010 both used tart cherry juice/concentrate and found modest melatonin increases and improved sleep time; this product is the same whole-juice form.
Improves sleep quality and duration
Pigeon 2010 showed roughly 84 minutes more sleep in insomniacs and Howatson 2012 showed longer sleep in healthy adults, but samples were small and effects modest, not on par with a sleep medication.
No added sugar or preservatives
Label states 100% pure Montmorency concentrate; sweetness is intrinsic fruit sugar, not added, consistent with the product's stated formulation.
What Our Test Actually Found
Best match for the sleep angle
The trace melatonin and anthocyanin package in whole concentrate is what nudged sleep time in the published trials. If sleep is why you're buying tart cherry, a concentrate beats any capsule here.
Whole food means variable dose
Because it isn't standardized to an anthocyanin percentage, batch-to-batch potency can drift. That's the honest cost of buying the trial-form rather than a lab-fixed extract.
Full analysis: all pros & cons (6), buy if / skip if
- Whole-juice form used in the actual sleep and recovery studies
- 100% pure Montmorency, no added sugar or preservatives
- Delivers natural melatonin plus anthocyanins that capsules lose
- Strong per-serving value for genuine concentrate
- Not a standardized extract; anthocyanin content varies by batch
- Requires mixing and refrigeration, and carries natural fruit sugar
- Whole-juice form used in the actual sleep and recovery studies
- 100% pure Montmorency, no added sugar or preservatives
- Delivers natural melatonin plus anthocyanins that capsules lose
- Not a standardized extract; anthocyanin content varies by batch
- Requires mixing and refrigeration, and carries natural fruit sugar
If your interest is the sleep/melatonin angle or you want to mirror the recovery trials, whole Montmorency concentrate beats capsules. Cherry Bay Orchards is clean (no added sugar, 100% juice) and works out to a fair per-serving cost. Downsides: you have to mix and refrigerate it, and it's a whole food, not a standardized dose.
Nearly every landmark tart cherry study, the marathon-recovery trials and the melatonin/sleep trials alike, used cherry juice or concentrate, not a capsule. Cherry Bay Orchards is exactly that: 100% pure Montmorency concentrate with no added sugar or preservatives, roughly one ounce (the equivalent of 60-plus cherries) mixed into water per serving. That whole-juice matrix delivers the natural anthocyanins and the trace melatonin that drive the sleep signal, which pills largely leave behind. The trade-offs are honest ones, it is not a standardized extract, it needs refrigeration and mixing, and the sugar comes along for the ride, but if you want the form the science was built on, this is it.
Buy this if sleep or trial-fidelity is your goal
For the sleep/melatonin benefit and for mirroring the recovery studies, whole concentrate is the right tool and Cherry Bay Orchards is a clean, fairly priced one. Choose the Sports Research softgel instead if you need portability and a named, standardized dose.
If This Doesn’t Fit — Try These
02Sports Research CherryPURE
For most people chasing recovery and sleep support, this is the smartest buy: a clinically-studied dose, a standardized extract, and a convenient softgel at a fair price.
04Zazzee 10:1 (200 Caps)
For a daily maintenance dose aimed at uric-acid and antioxidant support, this is the best value on the board — a real 10:1 concentrate at eleven cents a capsule.
Quick Answers
How do I take the concentrate?
Mix roughly one ounce with water once or twice daily; many sleep users take a serving 1-2 hours before bed. Refrigerate after opening.
Is it better than capsules?
For sleep, yes, because the studies used whole juice and its natural melatonin. For a fixed, portable anti-inflammatory dose, a standardized capsule like Sports Research is more convenient.
Sources & Further Reading
2 peer-reviewed sources, each linked to PubMed
- [1] Howatson G, et al. Eur J Nutr. 2012;51(8):909-16. PMID 22038497 — Effect of tart cherry juice (Prunus cerasus) on melatonin levels and enhanced sleep quality. Tart cherry juice raised urinary melatonin and increased sleep time and efficiency in healthy adults.
- [2] Pigeon WR, et al. J Med Food. 2010;13(3):579-83. PMID 20438325 — Effects of a tart cherry juice beverage on the sleep of older adults with insomnia: a pilot study. Tart cherry juice modestly reduced insomnia severity and increased sleep time in older adults, though effects were small.
Affiliate disclosure: every Amazon link uses our Associates tag (superachieverclub-20). We earn a small commission at no cost to you; it funds independent reviews. We never accept payment to change a ranking.