Reviewed

Verified by SAC team

+20

XP on completion

Cheapest Per Capsule

Carlyle

Carlyle Tart Cherry Capsules 200 (Max Potency) Review

Name: Carlyle Tart Cherry Capsules 200 (Max Potency)
Brand: Carlyle
Availability: InStock

5.8/10SAC Product Score™

Carlyle's 200-count 'Max Potency' bottle is the cheapest way to put tart cherry in your routine, and for a strictly budget-minded buyer that has a place. But cheap has costs here: it's a 4:1 extract dressed up as a 6,000 mg serving, there's no standardized anthocyanin content, and testing transparency is limited to a Non-GMO claim. It'll deliver some cherry polyphenols daily, and that's not nothing, but you're trading the concentration and quality assurance of the higher picks for price. It ranks near the bottom because value can never buy its way past standardization and testing on our method.

Check on Amazon

Affiliate link — Super Achiever Club earns a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Read the complete Tart Cherry guide →

▸ THE SCORE

How we built the SAC Product Score™ — 5.8/10

Form & Bioavailability25%5.5/10

Standard capsule with a 4:1 extract; lower concentration means fewer anthocyanins per serving than the 10:1 picks.

Standardization & Dose25%5.5/10

The 6,000 mg is a 4:1 raw equivalent with no anthocyanin standardization and minimal published potency data.

Third-Party Testing20%5/10

Non-GMO claim only; no published third-party certificate, sport certification, or contaminant data.

Tolerability & Safety15%6.5/10

Well tolerated as a simple cherry capsule; no sugar or stimulants.

Value15%7/10

~$13.99 for 200 capsules is the lowest cost per capsule here, its one genuine strength.

▸ SPECS

The product at a glance

Form: Capsule (4:1 extract)
Dose: 6,000 mg raw equivalent/serving
Count: 200 capsules
Standardization: 4:1 extract; not standardized
Testing: Non-GMO
Cost per dose: ~$0.07 per capsule

▸ TRUTH CHECK

Marketing claims vs. reality

Verified

“Lowest cost per capsule of any pick here”

At ~$13.99 for 200 capsules (~$0.07 each), it is the cheapest per-unit option on this list.

Partial

“'Max Potency' 6,000 mg serving”

The 6,000 mg is a 4:1 raw-cherry equivalent, not a high standardized dose; 'Max Potency' is marketing language, not a verified concentration advantage.

Not verified

“Provides clinically effective anti-inflammatory dosing”

With a weaker 4:1 extract, no anthocyanin standardization and no product-specific testing, there's no basis to claim it reaches a clinically studied dose.

▸ THE DEEP DIVE

What our test actually found

01Price is the only real selling point

At seven cents a capsule it's genuinely cheap, but the 4:1 ratio and absent testing mean you get what you pay for in concentration and assurance.

02'Max Potency' is a label, not a spec

The phrase carries no standardization behind it. Don't read it as stronger than the 10:1 extracts, which it isn't.

▸ THE TRADE-OFFS

Pros & cons, no sugar-coating

Pros

Cheapest cost per capsule on the list
High 200-count for a long budget supply
Simple, sugar-free daily cherry capsule
Widely available from a mainstream budget brand

Cons

Weaker 4:1 extract with no standardized anthocyanin content
Minimal testing transparency (Non-GMO claim only)

▸ THE BOTTOM LINE

For price-first buyers only

Carlyle makes sense if the lowest possible price is your deciding factor and you accept the weaker extract and thin testing. Anyone wanting real concentration or quality assurance should spend a little more on the 10:1 Zazzee or the studied Sports Research softgel.

Check Carlyle on Amazon

▸ ALTERNATIVES

If this doesn’t fit — try these

Zazzee Tart Cherry 10:1 (200 ct)

7/10

A little more money buys a genuine 10:1 extract and better labeling.

See it on the list →

Sports Research CherryPURE Softgels

8.4/10

The evidence-aligned pick if you want quality over rock-bottom price.

See it on the list →

▸ RESEARCH